Live Scholarly Event

The Ultimate Synoptic Showdown:
Did Q Exist?

Join two of the world's leading New Testament scholars for a historic, live weekend event exploring the foundations of the Gospels.

Did Q Exist? - Dr. Mark Goodacre vs Dr. John Kloppenborg
Feb 21st & 28th, 2025
4 Lectures + Live Discussion
Lifetime Access
Secure Your Spot Now
BSA Members: You have full access to the recordings as part of your membership.

Understanding the Synoptic Problem

The "Synoptic Problem" arises from the fact that the first three gospels share a large number of stories and sayings—sometimes with close agreement in wording and sequence—yet there are very significant differences in both the wording and the order of those stories and sayings.

For over a century, scholars have assumed that Matthew and Luke relied on a lost collection of Jesus' sayings known as "Q." But what if it never existed?

If Q is real, it offers our earliest glimpse into the history of Jesus. If it's a myth, our entire understanding of how the Gospels were written must be rewritten.

The Q Source Theory Diagram

Key Questions We'll Explore:

  • How do we best account for the combination of strong similarities and marked differences?
  • Can oral tradition account for the constellation of strong similarities?
  • Is it possible to identify the earliest gospel—and by what criteria?
  • How did the later gospels use the first gospel?
  • Is it necessary to posit sources that are no longer extant (like Q)?
  • Is there "unruly data" that defies or complicates any hypothesis?

The Four Lectures

A systematic exploration from two opposing scholarly perspectives.

Lecture 1 — Kloppenborg

Is the Relationship Literary or Oral?

Exploring whether the gospels' relationship is based on literary dependence or knowledge of oral traditions.

Lecture 2 — Goodacre

Mark as the Earliest Gospel

Examining the evidence that Mark was written first and served as a source for Matthew and Luke.

Lecture 3 — Kloppenborg

Non-Markan Material and the Positing of Q

How do we account for material shared by Matthew and Luke but absent from Mark? The case for Q.

Lecture 4 — Goodacre

Mark and Matthew as the Sources of Luke

The Farrer Hypothesis: Luke used both Mark and Matthew directly—dispensing with Q entirely.

Two Days That Will Change How You Read the Gospels

A comprehensive exploration of the Synoptic Problem featuring lectures, evidence, and a face-to-face scholarly discussion.

Day 1: The Evidence

Lectures & Discussion

Saturday, February 21st
1:00 PM – 5:00 PM ET
  • Two lectures presenting the case for Q's existence
  • Two lectures presenting the case against Q
  • Live Q&A and scholarly discussion
Day 2: The Discussion

Live Scholarly Discussion

Saturday, February 28th
2:00 PM – 3:20 PM ET
  • Direct discussion between Dr. Goodacre and Dr. Kloppenborg
  • Point-by-point responses and scholarly exchange
  • Audience questions and final statements

Meet the Scholars

Two world-renowned experts. Two opposing views. One defining question.

The Skeptic
Dr. Mark Goodacre

Dr. Mark Goodacre

Professor at Duke University

Famous for his "Case Against Q," Dr. Goodacre champions the Farrer Hypothesis—the idea that Luke used Matthew directly, making Q a modern fiction.

The Case Against Q

Author of "The Case Against Q"

The Proponent
Dr. John Kloppenborg

Dr. John Kloppenborg

Professor at University of Toronto

The world's leading authority on the reconstruction of Q. Dr. Kloppenborg is the editor of the Critical Edition of Q and has dedicated his career to proving its existence.

The Critical Edition of Q

Editor of "The Critical Edition of Q"

What's Included

Everything you need to master the Synoptic Problem and join the discussion.

Lifetime Access

Full recordings of all lectures and the live discussion, available forever in your course library.

Bonus Lesson

"The Mysteries of the Synoptic Gospels: Was Mark the First Gospel?"—a deep-dive bonus lecture.

Audio Downloads

Listen on the go with downloadable MP3 files of all sessions.

Early Bird Pricing

Did Q Exist? — All-Access Pass

Lock in your spot before February 7th

$59.95$49.95
  • Lifetime access to all lecture recordings
  • Live discussion recording included
  • Bonus lesson: Was Mark the First Gospel?
  • Downloadable audio for all sessions

30-Day Money-Back Guarantee

Not satisfied? Get a full refund within 30 days, no questions asked.

Secure Checkout
PayPal & Cards
Available Worldwide

Don't Miss This Historic Scholarly Discussion

Whether you're a scholar, student, or curious learner—this is your chance to witness two leading experts settle one of the most important questions in biblical studies.

Get Your All-Access Pass

$1 from your purchase is donated to charity: water

  • 01Customer
  • 02Payment

Enroll Today: Did Q Exist?

Contact information

Billing address

Payment information

You will not be charged for this purchase, but if you choose to make an optional purchase later, this card info will be used to complete that transaction!

Completing payment with PayPal